My position on this is really the same as my position on all public safety–and this affects both public and private spaces. In fact, my practical approach to this is why the Bus Drivers’ Union endorsed me–because they are very concerned about their own safety!
We need to prevent crime upstream, get the right response for the right crisis, ensure accountability and community legitimacy for that response, and reduce recidivism. Unless we do all these–our community will continue to suffer from being too unsafe.
Some prevention involves deep investment that pays dividends in future years. This means reversing the ways we’ve fostered unsafe conditions–reforming the way we build in this city so we no longer force people to live in concentrated poverty and away from opportunity or so that we build housing as fast as people move here, so our most vulnerable don’t get pushed onto the streets.
Some prevention involves investments that pay dividends on the order of weeks, months, or a year or two. We have to rebuild our human services and social safety net, providing direct assistance to poor families with children and young adults up to 25. For the fastest gains, we need to invest in evidence-based community violence intervention programming–like Community Passageways–that interrupts cycles of gun violence and gets the highest-risk people away from violence. These focus on access to jobs and positive activities, engagement with mentors, keeping young people busy with positive pursuits, and reducing access to guns for high-risk individuals–and it is proven to reduce gun violence. We do a lousy job at funding it.
We also have to send the right crisis responder or use the right tool for each crisis.
We need to send social workers to most behavioral health calls. They have more expertise and are less likely to violate people’s civil rights. Taking this load off can free up police time to respond more quickly, intervene in violent situations, and investigate sex crimes. Almost half of SPD calls don’t require an officer. We should do as Albuquerque has done and scale up this alternate response.
Most traffic violations should be automatic and camera-enforced. Traffic stops are where a great deal of racial bias has shown up in policing, and this can be automated to help an overstretched workforce. We just need to ensure we do not over-enforce in already marginalized neighborhoods and that there are safeguards to prevent inappropriate surveillance.
Police aren’t necessary for directing traffic at events or for administering Narcan either. Police should then be able to respond to the more acute situations – impending violence, violence in progress, investigating sex crimes, and the destruction of storefronts.
It must also be remembered that police hiring markets are dire–85% of jurisdictions in Washington State are below target. Nationally, most large cities are far from the target, and some–including even red cities like Tulsa, Memphis, and Suburban Atlanta–are as far from their staffing peaks (or nearly so) as Seattle. Tens of thousands have left the profession rebuilding this will take a long time. The problem is much bigger than us. So we need to do our very best to hire–but SPD says that realistically, even with bonuses and marketing–we will grow by 15 to 30 officers in the next year. Not the 400 that some politicians magically promise. So, the specialization I mentioned above is also imperative if we want any actual response to emergencies!
We also need accountable policing. Any attorney will tell you governance requires oversight – any CEO must submit to a board, and our entire government structure at the federal, state, and local levels is built around mutual oversight.
The King County Sheriff’s Department and Seattle’s Senior officers are increasingly moving toward real civilian oversight, but Seattle’s front is not. If our police are not accountable, they will continue to behave in ways that alienate the community, violate civil rights, and keep our city under the watchful eye of the Justice Department, which had to intervene because of our racially biased policing practices. Getting this right will protect our citizens and will begin to heal the relationship between the community and its enforcers.
We need to rehabilitate people whenever possible. We have decades of evidence that focused, evidence-based practice can significantly reduce reoffending rates and that just straight-up jailing someone may actually increase reoffending rates. We need to prioritize actual safety and use 21st-century, science-based practices, not use the justice system as a way to briefly vet our anger at defendants and create lifelong repeat offenders.